Malevitch, this is my white square!
"cast me forth into the sea, so shall the sea be calm unto you"
Today inadvertently the wound of love was open again and the blood and the tears came gushing out� And now Rumi:
The minute I heard my first love story,

This song "To A Teacher" (mp3) is dedicated to the great Canadian Jewish poet A. M. Klein. Words and music by Leonard Cohen from the DEAR HEATHER album.

Dr. Michael (Michoel) Wilensky address appeared in the Rebbe�s university registration records in Berlin.
Shaul Shimon Deutsch's writes on page 85 of the 2nd volume of the "Larger than life: The life and times of the Lubavitcher Rebbe Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson":
Dr. Michael (Michoel) Wilensky was the son of one of the most famous Chabad Chasidim. His father, Rabbi Chaim Ber Wilensky of Kremenchug, was considered one of the greatest minds in the area of Chasidic thought. He was known as one of the "Berelach" of Kremenchug. This was a phrase coined for a few great Chasidic scholars who were all named Ber who all lived in Kremenchug. The fifth Lubavitcher Rebbe, the Rebbe RaShaB said of Chaim Ber Wilensky that "he was capable of giving twenty-one explanations on the mystical concept of Ein Sof.
Chaim Ber had a son named Michoel. In his youth, Michoel studied at a Chabad yeshiva. However, he wanted a secular education and entered the university. He received his doctorate from the University of Berne in 1912 and went on to specialize in mathematics at the University of Kazan, Russia. After the 1917 Revolution, he settled in Odessa. There, his interest in Jewish studies was aroused by Chaim Nachman Bialik, and he worked on the staff of Tarbut until 1920.
In 1921, Michoel managed to leave Communist Russia for Berlin, along with a group of Jewish intellectuals headed by Chaim Nachman Bialik. In Berlin, he worked for Bialik at the Dvir Publishing Company.
While in Berlin, he edited Abraham Ibin Ezra's grammatical works, Safah Berurah and Moznayim. He contributed articles to historical journals and to the German Jewish Encyclopedia and worked with the Verein zur Gruendung einer Akademie fuer die Wissenschaft des Judentums. His principal accomplishment in Berlin was the publication, in 1929, of Jonah ibn Gnach's Sefer Ha- Rikimah. (The Sefer Rikimah was published by Wilensky in Berlin. Volume I was published in 1929 and Volume II in 1931. It was republished after Wilensky's death. With the help and advice of the Rebbe, Dr. Shimon Bernstein edited and republished the book in Jerusalem, in 1964. The title page of Sefer Ha-Rikimah lists Dr. Wilensky's address as the same one as provided by the Rebbe on his registration records at the University.)
Did the Rebbe have a good relationship with his landlord? The answer is most definitely yes. Their friendship lasted until the end of Michael Wilensky's life in 1955. Dr. Wilensky came to America in 1935 and was Manuscript Librarian at the Hebrew Union College in Cincinnati, the Reform rabbinical seminary. (See "The Refugee Scholars Project of the Hebrew Union College" by Michael Meyer. In Gary J. Robuck's article, "The Rescue of The European Scholar: The Hebrew Union College (1934-42)", he states: "In 1935, after careful consideration and inquiry, another call was issued. Dr. Michael Wilensky, a native of Russia living in Lithuania, was called to Cincinnati to catalog the manuscripts in the library. The terms of the call indicate that he should be hired for only one year at a salary of $2000.00. Presumably, Wilensky would return to Lithuania after the completion of his work."
However, in 1937, Wilensky was well ensconced in the college library and would stay there until his retirement. Separated from his wife and very alone culturally at the college, Wilensky quickly fell ill and proved quite some burdensome for Dr. Morgenstern. Dr. Wilensky, like many refugee scholars who came to this country, was so uncomfortable that Morgenstern was sufficiently aroused to compose a letter to Dr. Ismar Elbogen, head of the Hochshule Fur Die Wissenschaft Des Judentums, who had recommended Wilensky originally.
[Dr. Morgenstern wrote]: �We brought him here primarily not because we were so eager to have our manuscripts catalogued at just this particular time when our financial situation is anything but good, but because we felt obliged to do something for those Jewish scholars in distress. He has misunderstood his position here completely and it seems impossible to make him appreciative.�
According to Michael Meyer's article, Mrs. Wilensky wrote an emotional letter to Morgenstern claiming that, not only was there no work for her husband in Lithuania, but that leaving America could lead to a fatal stroke. The college then paid for a ticket for her to join her husband in America. He remained at his cataloging task until his retirement in 1943. He compiled a catalog of all the manuscripts in the institution's library. In his will, he left his private library of books and manuscripts to the Rebbe. (Told to the author [SSD] by Rabbi Aron Chitrik. Also mentioned in his letter to the editor published in the Algemeiner journal, Sept. 24,1994, p. B2.)
Not only did Wilensky will his library to the Rebbe; in his life-time, he gave the Rebbe four original handwritten books of Chasidus. Three of them were handwritten manuscripts of the Tzemach Tzedek (the third Lubavitcher Rebbe). In a letter the Rebbe sent to Wilensky he writes (Igrois Kodesh by the Rebbe. Vol. 9, pp.254-55. 11A. Ibid.): Knowing you from back then [a reference to Berlin], I would like to know how you are doing and if there is any way I can be of assistance to you. In that same letter the Rebbe also writes: Thank you for notifying me about the four bichlach [handwritten books of Chasidus - Translator's note], of which three are from the Tzemach Tzedek. I would like to know if their contents have already been printed or not. If there are any costs involved, I would be glad to pay them.
Wilensky, who was ill at the time, could not visit the Rebbe. However, the Rebbe sent Rabbi Yosef Goldstein to visit Wilensky and pick up the Chasidic manuscripts. Wilensky gave the Rebbe not only the books, but also a copy of a letter that he had received from the Previous Rebbe. The Rebbe also recalled his memories of Dr. Wilensky on various occasions. In one letter, the Rebbe wrote to Dr. Shimon Bernstein (who was involved in reprinting Wilensky's notes and corrections to Sefer Rikimah) about his memories of Dr. Wilensky in Berlin: I knew the deceased o.b.m. [a reference to Dr. Wilensky]. He was very talented and very meticulous. I was in Berlin when Dr. Wilensky was working on his book. I saw him totally engrossed, spending days and nights on his book. In a fascinating letter which I discovered in the Genazim archives (Hebrew Poets Society) in Israel, written by the Rebbe to Mrs. Wilensky, the Rebbe writes with high praise of the late Dr. Wilensky.
When the Rebbe was informed of Dr. Wilensky death, he sent R. Yisroel Jacobson to Cincinnati to represent him at the Funeral. Dr. Samuel Atlas a colleague of Wilensky in HUC wrote a very interesting letter to R. Y.Y. Weinberg describing the events surrounding Wilensky death and funeral.
end of SSD quote.1938 Hebrew Union College copied the 1933 effort by New School University in establishing a School for European scholars. HUC initiated a rescue effort of 10 prominent scholars to form "The Jewish School in Exile":
Sometimes you have an epiphany and sometimes things stew slowly in your mind until they reach a point where they need a release. Ever since high school (at MTA), when I read Yechezkel Kaufmann's The Religion of Israel, I have been suspicious of the intellectual honesty of my rabbis. While in YU I was called a "pinko" (very popular back in the 70's) by one (then) young rav of mine for questioning a moral conclusion of a statement in the gemara.
My questions are these: Do the rabbis of today fear that the abandonment of dogma will lead to the abandonment of Halakhic practice or do they fear the abandonment of dogma in and of itself? Do they not trust that our 3,000 year intellectual history can withstand the challenges of contemporary science, philosophy and in the broadest sense of the term, sociology? Or do they really believe, that the dogma's that we have been taught are so much a part of our belief in God, that without them, we might as well not keep the Shabbat?
read the great post.
OK, everyone is linking to the RADAR's investigative report on the Hollywood's Hottest Cult. Part One and Part Two have been published and conclusion is due on Monday.
The expose is somewhat informative and rather amusing. I am not sure I still understand what exactly is the New Age and why it is wrong to try to communicate to others in a language they understand? But I found the following approach interesting:
The Bergs haven�t relied just on rabbis for help. The Centre sometimes hires ghostwriters to produce its books. The Centre has advertised for writers on the website Craigslist. In keeping with the Centre�s increasingly aggressive plan to expand, according to sources, the writers are urged to study spiritual best-sellers and mimic them using Kabbalah Centre lingo. Many of the Centre�s new books are stripped of Jewish context.
Also since PR mongering and fundraising is the most respectful profession in Lubavitch today and like Larry Seinfeld used to say "nothing wrong with that", so why do they pick on Bergs? There is a thirst for spiritually in this country and the phonies of the world, TV evangelist, etc, run the most profitable business around. Heck some of the Lubavitchers certainly make a ruble or two selling food for the soul. And as we know Lubavitchers can do New Age with the best of them.
I also need to read something form Bergs to form an opion on their content. But when Philp Berg is quoted saying: "Stay away from the frum, they will chew you up for breakfast and spit you out for dinner"- I can�t help but think that this sounds true.
Rabbi Yitzchok Hanoka who is married to Berel Levy�s granddaughter was visiting his parents in Boston for Shovues. So I asked Yitzchok what he knows about R. Levy and what he knows about his connection to the Malach. Evidently he knew little beyond the article that was written by his father in law R. Don Yoel Levy. Then on Friday an interesting information surfaced from the "Transcriber" (see Apart from the Melochim but never removed).
The "Transcriber" contributes this taped talk by the Malach�s son R. Refoel Zalman. We publish it here as is and in all probability this is the first time this information sees the light of day. Some of the words are missing as in the original tape recording.
Rabbi Refoel Zalman's Feter Berel [R. B. Levy�s grandfather] and Nephew Berel [R. B. Levy nephew of the Malach]
I remember once there was a boy who went to yeshiva and then there was a rumor that he [some man named Hershel] spoiled the yeshiva, that he got mitzhametz. So he became a Hebrew teacher. So, I don't know if it was Chanukah, it was some kind of a Yom Tov it came Shabbos morning. Shabbos always in the morning, about 4:00 we would get up and go in shul, because in the house there was no light. So it burned down all the lights, but there is light in shul. So I met Hershel, his name was Hershel. So I was talking to him. My Feter Berel [Berel Levy�s grandfather] was sitting there, maraving the sedra, whatever. Because he couldn't learn, my Feter Berel was not a lamden. But, you know, he would say Tehillim, marave the sedra and I think that he used to learn Shulchon Oruch every day, too, and that's all. So he sees me and he pulls me over. He said, "Tur mit em nit raiden. Tur nish mit em raiden. Er iz gevoren a Hebrew teacher. Gae ahaim und gae shlofen." This was my Feter Berel. "Nish raiden, gae shloft."
You don't see, nowadays, his type. Such an oxshen, such an oxshen, you couldn't move him! Especially when it came to the shtible, aiin klainikyte. Everything had to be like our forefathers did. Any improvement. For instance, they wanted to make better benches, because the benches were just? . So they made a motion. No! "Because oib mir darfen hobben good benches, zay would have und oib zay halten nisht azoy mir darft nisht."
What happen to his children? None of them, none of them. I'll tell you something: Once I asked my father, because Berel [R. Berel Levy], he was born here in America and when he became a Baal Tshuva he must have been about? . How did he become, Berel? It happened that my father had a friend, Weiler [this is collaborated in the Don Yoel's article]. Weiler had a son who was a teacher in a Talmud Torah. Berel's parents lived also in the Bronx not far from my father, but they never had to do, anything with my father. So the teacher tells his father Mr. Weiler, so he said to him, "Der Rebben's nephew [R. B. Levy], he has an inclination more to Hebrew than to his English." So he said that it would be more appropriate that they should take him out and send him to Yeshiva D'Bronx.
So Weiler once came to my father and told him what his son said in the conversation. So my father was tsukrigged with the Yeshiva D'Bronx said to Weiler that maybe he can influence him he should come to my father and send him to Torah V'Das. It was very easy, because Weiler was going from the same station, since they lived? from my father it was about 10 blocks, but from Weiler it was close. In other words, if you have to take the subway, you have to take the Jill[?] Avenue to both of them. So he could go with Weiler and come back with Weiler, because he was too young, yet.
So the following z'man, before Succos, he started going into Torah V'Das. My father spoke to Mendelovitch and told him he should take him in and, of course, he took him in. So this Berel, he started to become? he went there up to about Chanukah. So it came about Chanunkah, about five or six or eight weeks he would come Friday. He would come home, because in Yeshiva Torah V'Das they would learn half a day, only until 1:00. Then he would come home and stay home.
One Friday he comes home, he takes a bath and all dressed up and he goes. He's goes away, he told his mother, he's going back to yeshiva. So, his mother starts hollering, what are you meshugga? She says, do you have a place where to sleep? He will find it. What's the matter? He says, "I cannot eat in your house, because you cook on Shabbos." So she got excited, you know. After all, he is her child. She forgot that she is not supposed to. So she got excited, she said, "Okay, let's see. Let's go to your uncle and if he will tell you to go, I will let you go. Because I know," she says, "that he will tell you to be home." She forgot that she will get h---.
So she comes with him to my father, Friday. So my father gave her, he gave her. He said, "You goyka ira!" You know what goyka means? You goya. "Berel's in tsoras because l'kovod Shabbos!" My father couldn't imagine. He said, "Berel," zogt er, "zol hobben Shabbos by mir. Okay, let him stay here. And ich tur by dir du tur nish tuen a melocho oiched." L'kovod Shabbos!
To make a long story short, what could she do? She wanted him to poskin the shila. She had to throw out all of her dishes.
The reason I tell you all of this is because I want you to know his background, Berel's background. And he was getting frummer every week. I would come to New York, so my father would tell me about Berel. Because Berel was born the week when we arrived here. My father was to the bris, yet, about three days? we came Friday and in the week was the bris. So I know how old is Berel, I remember when he was born and I know the story.
So, I once asked my father, how come? After all, his upbringing: he didn't have an upbringing. His origin: he is not a kosher child, anyway. So how come it should be? So, you know what my father said? My father says, he said, it's not surprising to him. He said, the meserios nefesh from his Feter Berel. So, of all the family, he finally won. My father told me this way.
So my father says to mir, "Kenst zennen from the Gemorrah. The Gemorrah says that you shouldn't marriv an ooilay an av lay. Even if a child is not frum, you dare not distinguish him from the other children if you aing given the yerusha. Why? Because the Gemorrah says you don't know what in the future generations will come out. Therefore, he, himself, okay, it's all right. But you see it comes out a generation or two later. This is what happened, he said, with Berelen. He's Feter Berel's an ainikel. It came from Feter Berel. This is what my father told me about Berel. He never saw his grandfather. His grandfather died before my mother even. So he died about five, six years before we left for America.
"Well there is not much I can do about it. I have already posted that I do not feel financially or emotionally able to raise a child by myself right now and also I do not intellectually feel comfortable with the idea of bringing a child into the world without a father, when there are so many babies available for adoption who have no parent at all. But it is interesting that the physical instinct to be a mother is so strong. And it is very hard to overcome one�s physical instincts. It seems that so much of my life is about that. Which leads me back to the question, by lifting myself above my physical instincts, am I being holy, or am I being stupid?"
Too bad Rabbi Kotel Da-Don was dismissed. We understand that your comity is very small. But no matter how small it is there is room for competition. Seek alternative financial resources. Create new unaffiliated synagogue, school and kindergarten. Start small and lead by example. Do not try to reform an organization and an institution with a record of chronic failure. This is terribly complicated because the scares resources are under the thumb of the reactionaries. But we have no other choice in Zagreb, in Boston and virtually in every place where there is a Jewish community. We need to start from scratch.
But then again some say the Europe is finished not only for Jews. Washington Post: The End of Europe.
I first met Berel Levy in Moscow in 1978 or 79. I remember it very well. I walked into the Kleiner Beis Medrash in the Archipova Shule. I think it was a fast day because there was a Kriyas HaTeyre on Mincha. Next to Berel Levy who was wearing a Russian fur hat was Michoel Shneider. This was also the first time I have seen Michoel, who is one of the most significant personalities amongst Russian Jewry in the past 30 years.
Michoel had bushy peyos then, a stunning picture in Moscow. I remember the entire scene as if it was today. I remember how Michoel Shneider was given a Hagba, how he raised the Torah and how he found his way to sit down on the elevated bench behind the bimah.
I have later spent a many Shabosim davening next to Berl Levy in the Simpson Shule in Boro Park. He looked at me with an air of presumed superiority. Never talking to me on a personal level. Never asking me a direct question. Considering his constant yapping about his achievements in Russia this lack of intellectual curiosity was glaring. The only time I have seen him speaking with passion about a subject was when he delivered his "vinegar" defense (some of you might still remember the story). I have to say that he fit in Boro Park rather well. Avrohom Aaron Rubashkin remained a Neveler but Berel Levy became a Boro Parker through and through. But this is not the subject really.
Berel Levy�s grandfather was Malach�s brother. The Malach was Berel Levy�s inspiration. Don Yoel Levy writes:
"Growing up in America in the 1920's, outside of New York City, was not conducive for someone wishing to be an observant Jew. Consequently, at the age of ten, a young Berel decided to leave home and move in with his uncle. The move enabled him to attend the Yeshiva Torah V�Daas. The subway ride to Torah V'Daas was over an hour and Rabbi Weiler, a Torah V'Daas teacher, would accompany my father and learn with him each way.
Berel Levy's uncle, Avrohom Ber Levine, was known as "the Angel". He was recognized as an extremely devout and brilliant person. In those years, assimilation was becoming a real problem for the Jewish community. Thus, Rabbi Mendelovitz, the principal of Torah V'Daas, asked Rabbi Levine to teach Chassidus to some of the older students. He included his nephew, young Berel, among his students. Rabbi Levine had a strong influence on these students and many of them refused to continue their public high school education. Rabbi Levine was a man of impeccable habits. His desire to do the correct thing, no matter what others would say or do, deeply affected my father at that time and for the rest of his life. There were times in those years that my father, having no other place to sleep, would spend nights on a bench in the shul.
Even without much previous religious training, my father utilized his prodigious capabilities to their fullest to become an outstanding student. When he was sixteen, his uncle passed away. My father's spiritual guide, Rabbi Yisroel Jacobson, gave him constant guidance and, at his suggestion, my father decided to leave Torah V'Daas to go to the Lubavitcher Yeshiva in Otwock, Poland. He received no money from his parents and raised the money for the journey himself."
One can get an idea of the Malach's hashkofes and deyes in Otzar Igres Kodesh put out without his name. This volume contains letters to his son Rav Zalman and I believe to Rabbi Asher Zelig Magalioth an interesting Polish Jew in Jerusalem who turned extremist. Recently a short bio of the malach was included in a collected bio of the first 3 "deyres" of Lubavitch Chabad. The author is Lemel Schwartz. I will not comment on the quality of the book. I am certain(?) that these books are available in Williamsburg book stores. A nephew of the current leader of the group now a professor of geography in Hawaii has written a bio "on line" in English of his grandfather Mr. B. Z. Weberman which includes data on the Malach as this lawyer was very close to Rav levine.
The point is that in all matters holy and refined and important, it is the easiest to go wrong. As was once said about Shir Hashirim, the holiest of books: the problem is not that it is difficult to understand, but that it is so easy to misunderstand.
This is true even before we take into account an active desire to actually misconstrue what the Rebbe/chassidus in general has to say on the subject. Chassidus explains that the main quality of the Sefirah of Chochmah is Bittul. In practical application, that may mean that any true Chacham must posses the humility of approach necessary to understand what is going on, rather than presumptuously preach and dismiss it.
As Rabbi Immanuel Schochet wrote a few years ago, both the Chabad-haters and lunatic fringe of Lubavitch have exactly this point in common: the presumptuousness that precludes any real understanding, let alone communication. In this respect, they are in reality two sides of one and the same coin.